Call us for a free consultation
Call us for a free consultation
When a lawyer you trusted makes a serious mistake, your case, your money, and your legal rights can all suffer the consequences. Legal malpractice can occur in virtually any area of law, from personal injury and real estate matters to business disputes, estate planning, and family law cases. When an attorney’s negligence causes a missed opportunity, lost claim, or unfavorable outcome that could have been avoided, Massachusetts law may provide a path to recover your losses.
At Colucci, Colucci & Marcus, P.C., Boston legal malpractice lawyer Dino M. Colucci represents clients in Boston and throughout Massachusetts who have been harmed by attorney negligence, missed deadlines, conflicts of interest, and other forms of legal malpractice. Our team works to hold negligent lawyers accountable and recover the compensation their clients lost.
On this page, you’ll learn what constitutes legal malpractice in Massachusetts, the elements required to prove a claim, the deadlines that apply, the damages that may be available, and the steps involved in pursuing a malpractice lawsuit against a negligent attorney.
If you believe your attorney’s mistake cost you a case, settlement, or other valuable legal right, contact Colucci, Colucci & Marcus, P.C. today. Call (617) 698-6000 to discuss your situation and learn whether you may have a legal malpractice claim.
Every Injury Case Deserves Personal Attention
Confidential Consultation with Experienced Trial Attorney
Recent Case results
Serving Clients Throughout
Massachusetts,
New England, and
Across the United States
When the stakes are high, put a proven personal injury law firm on your side.
Very happy with the care, attention and service I received from everyone at Colucci Colucci & Marcus at Law. From day one, everyone was kind, professional and outstanding advocates for me during a very stressful time in my life. I am very happy with the settlement I received. Stephanie & Junyan were kind…
Professional, Honest, and Responsive
I cannot recommend Attorney Matt Marcus enough for anyone seeking estate planning services. What truly set him apart was his professional integrity, right from the very start…
Darin is a great lawyer, works with his clients, and goes all out for everything they can get. Above that, he has the best assistant, Allison, she is always there to help when Darin is doing his outside work. I will recommend this agency to get you everything you deserve…
Every Injury Case Deserves Personal Attention
Confidential Consultation with Experienced Trial Attorney
Legal malpractice occurs when an attorney fails to meet the professional standard of care owed to a client, and that failure causes the client to suffer financial harm.
To succeed on a legal malpractice claim in Massachusetts, a plaintiff must prove four elements, all of which must be established by a preponderance of the evidence:
If any one element is missing, the claim fails.
Not every unfavorable result in a legal case amounts to malpractice. Attorneys exercise professional judgment on matters of strategy, and a losing case does not automatically mean the lawyer did something wrong. If a reasonably competent lawyer could have made the same decision under the same circumstances, there is no breach, even if the outcome was not what the client hoped for.
Key Takeaway: Legal malpractice in Massachusetts requires proof of four elements: duty, breach, causation, and damages. A bad outcome alone does not establish a claim. The attorney’s conduct must have fallen below the standard expected of a reasonably competent lawyer.
Determining whether an attorney’s conduct amounts to legal malpractice often requires a careful review of what happened in the underlying case and the harm that resulted. To discuss your situation and learn whether you may have a valid legal malpractice claim, call Colucci, Colucci & Marcus, P.C. at (617) 698-6000.
I cannot express enough gratitude for the outstanding representation and compassion I received from Colucci, Colucci & Marcus, especially Darin Colucci. From the very first conversation, Darin made me feel like more than just a client—he treated me like family. Navigating the aftermath of my accident was one of the most challenging times of my life…
Attorney negligence can take many forms, and Boston clients bring malpractice claims arising from a wide range of legal matters, including missed deadlines, settlement errors, undisclosed conflicts of interest, and inadequate investigation.
Failing to file a lawsuit or claim before the applicable statute of limitations expires is one of the most frequent bases for legal malpractice claims. When an attorney allows a filing deadline to pass, the client’s underlying case may be lost, regardless of how strong it was.
An attorney who fails to communicate a settlement offer, advises a client to accept an unreasonably low offer without adequate analysis, or settles a case without the client’s authorization may be liable for malpractice. Under the Massachusetts Rules of Professional Conduct Rule 1.4, attorneys have a duty to keep clients reasonably informed about the status of their case and to promptly communicate all settlement offers.
When an attorney represents two clients with adverse interests, or has a personal or financial interest that conflicts with a client’s case, the representation may be compromised from the start. The Massachusetts Rules of Professional Conduct Rule 1.7 prohibits representation where a concurrent conflict of interest exists unless specific conditions are met, including informed written consent from each affected client.
Attorneys are expected to prepare adequately for their clients’ cases. Failing to conduct basic legal research, missing controlling precedent, neglecting to pursue relevant discovery, or overlooking key evidence can all constitute a breach of the standard of care.
Key Takeaway: Common malpractice scenarios in Boston include missed filing deadlines, settlement errors, undisclosed conflicts of interest, and failure to investigate. Each of these errors can seriously harm a client’s legal rights.
If any of these situations sound familiar, it may be worth taking a closer look at how your case was handled and whether avoidable errors affected the outcome. To discuss concerns about missed deadlines, settlement issues, conflicts of interest, or other attorney mistakes, call Colucci, Colucci & Marcus, P.C. at (617) 698-6000.
Filing outside the limitations period can lead to dismissal, even when the malpractice appears clear, unless tolling, delayed accrual, or another exception applies.
Massachusetts law provides a three-year statute of limitations for legal malpractice claims under G.L. c. 260, § 4. The clock generally begins to run when the client knew, or reasonably should have known, that they suffered appreciable harm and that the harm was caused by the attorney’s conduct.
The discovery rule can delay when the three-year period begins to run in cases where the malpractice was not immediately apparent. For example, if an attorney failed to include a critical term in a contract, the harm might not become evident until years later when a dispute arises. The three-year clock would generally begin when the client discovered, or reasonably should have discovered, appreciable harm and its connection to the attorney’s error.
Although the discovery rule adjusts the start date of the limitations period in cases of latent harm, waiting to pursue a claim creates practical problems. Witnesses can become unavailable, documents may be lost or destroyed, and memories inevitably fade.
Key Takeaway: Massachusetts generally provides three years to file a legal malpractice claim. Because determining when the limitations period begins can be complex, consulting an attorney promptly is important.
Questions about when a legal malpractice claim accrued can become just as important as the underlying attorney error itself. If you are concerned that a filing deadline may affect your rights, call Colucci, Colucci & Marcus, P.C. at (617) 698-6000 to discuss the circumstances of your case.
Your Recovery Starts With One Call
Talk Directly with a Seasoned Attorney About Your Case
Exceptional firm! They are excellent in all the areas of law that they practice. They did an amazing job assisting my parents with their affairs in their elder years and are incredible personal injury attorneys. Our family has been using them for almost 20 years now and it’s proven to have been the best decision we ever made…
Your Family's Future Depends on the Right Attorney
30 Years of Proven Results in Boston’s Most Serious Injury Cases
Legal malpractice claims have a unique causation requirement: the plaintiff must prove not only that the attorney made an error, but also that the underlying legal matter would have produced a better result if the attorney had performed competently.
Under this standard, the malpractice plaintiff effectively tries two cases in one. First, the plaintiff must prove that the attorney’s conduct breached the standard of care. Second, the plaintiff must demonstrate what the outcome of the underlying case would have been if handled properly. If the underlying case would have been lost anyway, even with competent representation, then the attorney’s error did not cause any recoverable damage.
The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court applied this framework in Fishman v. Brooks, 396 Mass. 643 (1986). For example, if an attorney missed the deadline to file a personal injury lawsuit, the malpractice plaintiff must prove that the personal injury case would have succeeded and what the likely recovery would have been.
Key Takeaway: Massachusetts requires legal malpractice plaintiffs to prove the “case within a case,” meaning you must show your underlying case would have succeeded but for the attorney’s error. Expert testimony is usually required to establish the standard of care and breach.
To discuss whether an attorney’s error may have affected the outcome of your legal matter, call Colucci, Colucci & Marcus, P.C. at (617) 698-6000.
When you successfully prove that an attorney’s negligence harmed your legal rights, you can recover financial compensation. The exact damages you receive depend on the details of your original case.
The primary financial recovery is the actual value of the underlying claim you lost. Additional economic damages can include:
Emotional distress damages are rarely awarded in Massachusetts legal malpractice cases. The law typically limits these claims to financial losses. Courts only allow exceptions in rare situations where emotional distress was a highly foreseeable consequence—such as a client being wrongfully sent to prison or committed to a mental hospital due to a lawyer’s extreme neglect.
One powerful exception is G.L. c. 93A (the Massachusetts Consumer Protection Act). This law applies if the attorney’s conduct was intentionally unfair or deceptive, rather than just a careless mistake. A successful Chapter 93A claim can award up to double or triple (treble) damages and cover your reasonable attorney’s fees. However, standard negligence claims do not allow for punitive damages under Massachusetts law.
If you believe an attorney’s mistake cost you money, a settlement, a business opportunity, or another valuable legal right, call Colucci, Colucci & Marcus, P.C. at (617) 698-6000 to discuss your potential claim.
Dino M. Colucci is the founding partner of Colucci, Colucci & Marcus, P.C. and has spent more than three decades representing clients in complex civil litigation matters throughout Massachusetts. His practice includes legal malpractice, medical malpractice, nursing home negligence, product liability, and other high-stakes negligence claims involving significant financial and personal losses.
As the firm’s lead trial counsel, Dino has handled a wide range of challenging cases and has earned recognition from Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly, The Best Lawyers in America, Massachusetts Super Lawyers, and Martindale-Hubbell. His extensive courtroom experience and background in complex negligence litigation provide valuable insight when pursuing claims against attorneys whose mistakes have harmed their clients.
Darin Colucci is the managing partner of Colucci, Colucci & Marcus, P.C. and represents clients in complex litigation and negligence matters throughout Massachusetts. His practice includes legal malpractice claims as well as serious personal injury, product liability, nursing home negligence, business litigation, and wrongful death cases.
Known for his trial advocacy and litigation experience, Darin has helped secure significant verdicts and settlements in complex cases involving catastrophic injuries, professional negligence, and business disputes. He has been recognized by Massachusetts Super Lawyers, The National Trial Lawyers Top 100, and other legal organizations for his work on behalf of injured clients.
Matthew J. Marcus is a partner at Colucci, Colucci & Marcus, P.C. with a practice focused on estate planning, elder law, disability law, and related legal matters. He brings decades of experience advising individuals and families on long-term planning, guardianships, and issues affecting elderly and disabled individuals.
In addition to his legal practice, Matthew has served as a Hearing Officer for the Massachusetts Board of Bar Overseers and has held leadership positions within several elder law organizations. His background reflects the firm’s commitment to providing experienced legal counsel across a broad range of legal matters.
Filing a legal malpractice lawsuit in Massachusetts involves several distinct stages, each of which requires careful preparation and strategic decision-making by your attorney.
The process begins with a thorough review of your underlying legal matter. A legal malpractice attorney will examine the original case file, the actions your prior attorney took or failed to take, and the outcome of the underlying matter to determine whether the four elements of malpractice can be established.
The attorney will gather additional evidence, including correspondence, court filings, billing records, and documentation from the prior representation. A qualified legal expert will be retained to evaluate the standard of care and provide an opinion on breach.
Most attorneys carry professional liability insurance, and an insurer may become involved in the defense or settlement of a malpractice claim. The legal claim itself is usually brought against the attorney or law firm, not directly against the insurer. A legal malpractice attorney may prepare and send a demand letter outlining the basis for the claim and damages sought, especially when a demand is required under Chapter 93A or useful for settlement negotiations.
Understanding the steps involved in a legal malpractice case can help you make informed decisions about how to move forward after discovering a potential attorney error. To learn more about the legal malpractice process and what may be involved in pursuing a claim, call Colucci, Colucci & Marcus, P.C. at (617) 698-6000.
A Board of Bar Overseers (BBO) complaint and a civil malpractice action can be pursued simultaneously, but neither one requires the other. The difference between these two processes helps you make informed decisions about how to respond to attorney misconduct.
| Feature | BBO Disciplinary Complaint | Civil Malpractice Lawsuit |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Protect the public and regulate attorney conduct | Compensate the injured client for financial losses |
| Filed With | Massachusetts Board of Bar Overseers | Massachusetts Superior Court or federal court |
| Who Benefits | The public (no money paid to complainant) | The client (money damages awarded to plaintiff) |
| Standard | Violation of Rules of Professional Conduct | Negligence: duty, breach, causation, damages |
| Possible Outcomes | Reprimand, suspension, disbarment | Monetary judgment or settlement |
| Attorney Fee Recovery | Not available | Available under Chapter 93A in qualifying cases |
| Required First | Not a prerequisite for a civil claim | Not a prerequisite for a BBO complaint |
A BBO complaint may result in sanctions against the attorney, including suspension or disbarment, but it does not provide financial compensation. A civil malpractice lawsuit is the only way to recover money for the harm you suffered.
Take the First Step Toward Recovery
Your Injury. Your Story. Your Justice
An uninsured motorist struck me from behind at the end of my driveway while I was shoveling. And was seriously injured. My case was handled with the highest expertise, support and with excellent customer service. I did not expect to have it settled so quickly and was pleasantly surprised with the results. I highly recommend this group…
I had a wonderful experience with Dino and his entire team from CCM when I was involved in an accident while cycling at fault of a motor vehicle driver resulting in multiple injuries. Dino was compassionate and actionable when we first got in touch, and throughout the entire settlement process always made himself available for any questions I had…
Learn more
Legal malpractice cases are among the most difficult civil claims to litigate. The defendant is another lawyer, often represented by experienced defense counsel retained by a professional liability insurer. The case-within-a-case standard means you are effectively litigating two matters at once, and insurance adjusters are familiar with the legal arguments and will challenge every element of your case.
These cases require an attorney who understands both trial litigation and the substantive law underlying the original case. A malpractice lawyer must identify precisely where the prior attorney went wrong, retain the right expert, and prove what the outcome of the underlying case should have been.
Colucci, Colucci & Marcus, P.C. is based at 424 Adams St #101 in Milton, Massachusetts, and represents legal malpractice clients throughout the state. Our team regularly handles cases in Suffolk County Superior Court in Boston, Norfolk County Superior Court in Dedham, and courts across Plymouth County, Middlesex County, and beyond.
If you believe your former attorney’s mistakes cost you a case, a fair settlement, or significant money, you have the right to hold that attorney accountable. Legal malpractice claims are time-sensitive, and the sooner you consult with an experienced lawyer, the stronger your position will be.
Legal malpractice lawyer Dino M. Colucci and the attorneys at Colucci, Colucci & Marcus, P.C. have spent decades handling complex civil litigation in Boston and across Massachusetts. Clients throughout Greater Boston and the state trust Colucci, Colucci & Marcus, P.C. to take on difficult legal malpractice cases and fight for the compensation they deserve.
Call Colucci, Colucci & Marcus, P.C. at (617) 698-6000 to schedule your free consultation. Our office is located at 424 Adams St #101, Milton, MA 02186, and serves clients throughout Greater Boston and all of Massachusetts.
You have three years under G.L. c. 260, § 4. The clock generally starts when you knew or reasonably should have known that you suffered appreciable harm and that it was connected to the attorney’s conduct. The discovery rule may extend your deadline, but it is not a guarantee, and acting promptly is always advisable.
Yes, in some circumstances. If your attorney’s negligence led you to accept a settlement significantly below the fair value of your case, or if the attorney settled without your authorization, you may have a valid malpractice claim.
Generally, yes. Massachusetts courts require expert testimony to establish the standard of care and whether it was breached. The exception covers errors so obvious that a layperson could recognize the negligence without expert help, which is rare.
You must prove actual damages to succeed. If you won the underlying case, showing financial harm may be difficult. However, you may still have a claim if you incurred unnecessary fees, experienced a delay, or received less than you would have without the error.
Yes, if the attorney’s conduct constituted unfair or deceptive business practices under G.L. c. 93A. Successful claims can result in up to treble damages and attorney’s fees. A written demand letter generally must be sent at least 30 days before filing suit. Business-context claims under § 11 do not have the same pre-suit demand-letter requirement.
A BBO complaint can result in sanctions against the attorney but does not pay you any money. A civil malpractice lawsuit is how you seek financial compensation. You can pursue both processes simultaneously.
Any licensed attorney in any practice area can be sued for malpractice if their negligence caused you harm, including attorneys handling personal injury, criminal defense, estate planning, real estate, family law, and business transactions. There is no category of legal work that is exempt from the professional standard of care.
Professional, Honest, and Responsive
I cannot recommend Attorney Matt Marcus enough for anyone seeking estate planning services. What truly set him apart was his professional integrity, right from the very start…
Very happy with the care, attention and service I received from everyone at Colucci Colucci & Marcus at Law. From day one, everyone was kind, professional and outstanding advocates for me during a very stressful time in my life. I am very happy with the settlement I received. Stephanie & Junyan were kind…
Darin is a great lawyer, works with his clients, and goes all out for everything they can get. Above that, he has the best assistant, Allison, she is always there to help when Darin is doing his outside work. I will recommend this agency to get you everything you deserve…